PDA

View Full Version : Which image do you prefer?

beech
11-06-08, 15:46
As above no.1 or no.2?
1.
http://i287.photobucket.com/albums/ll147/beech08/mushies2.jpg
2.
http://i287.photobucket.com/albums/ll147/beech08/mushie3.jpg

3. Neither!
Espocrespo
11-06-08, 15:49
1
Wee-Man
11-06-08, 15:50
1 looks a little photoshopped, so 2 is better and more natural.
TerraC
11-06-08, 15:50
1
aquadorge
11-06-08, 15:56
1 is more vibrant, but 2 looks more natural
beech
11-06-08, 16:00
1 is more vibrant, but 2 looks more natural

Aha but which do you prefer?:D
Jules
11-06-08, 16:03
1 'looks' better but is a little over 'shopped... inbetween 1 and 2 would be better!
aquadorge
11-06-08, 16:11
If I had to frame one to put on my wall then '1', but the purist says '2' (I'll just climb off that fence now before I get splinters in my bum....)
Red
11-06-08, 18:58
1 as i'm quite sure the colours are much similar to the naked eye than to what the camera caught in photo 2
babyreefer
11-06-08, 19:23
if they didn't photoshop models, no one would want to look at them!!!

photoshop no 1 is the one i prefer....

i think its the sadist in me that enjoys being disappointed when i see something, and then go out to find one myself, and i can never get one just as good than what the other guy has!!! "the one that got away"
SCOOB
11-06-08, 19:43
picture 1) is over saturated, picture 2) is over exposed.

tone down the saturation and stop the exposure down a couple of points and you'd have two great images.

jmho
beech
12-06-08, 00:13
picture 1) is over saturated, picture 2) is over exposed.

tone down the saturation and stop the exposure down a couple of points and you'd have two great images.

jmho

Your with 3 then :laugh:
Thanks for the advice. Though no 1 was a little over saturated too. what i see in my tank is somewhere in between. well done jules
lenny
14-06-08, 11:07
two for me as the colours are more natural and not p/shoped. len
lenny
14-06-08, 11:14
if they didn't photoshop models, no one would want to look at them!!!




photoshop no 1 is the one i prefer....

i think its the sadist in me that enjoys being disappointed when i see something, and then go out to find one myself, and i can never get one just as good than what the other guy has!!! "the one that got away"

yes but what about all the young girls trying to live upto these photoshopped pictures of girls in magazines.why is there skin full of defect ect when the models all look great . i do not think its that good to put up fause pictures like that. ilike to see it as my eye does not some imaginary person that can never be found in the real world. lol........... picture two for me.....len
pinkpony
14-06-08, 11:52
1
Paul
14-06-08, 12:49
#3 :)
darkrichard
24-06-08, 19:36
no 1 is the one i prefer
jimwil22
15-07-08, 08:13
enjoy this discussion ------- try different composition too --- if we
are able to make it more beautiful to the eye , it is understandable
Philfish
15-07-08, 08:19
1. It only looks so photoshopped next to the other one. If you look at it in isolation, it's not so noticeable.